Add discussion of copying conveience macros

Namely LOCAL_INPUT_DECLARE() and friends

Signed-off-by: David Horstmann <david.horstmann@arm.com>
This commit is contained in:
David Horstmann 2024-03-18 14:12:12 +00:00
parent 1c3b227065
commit 5ea99af0f2

View File

@ -569,6 +569,52 @@ psa_status_t psa_crypto_local_output_free(psa_crypto_local_output_t *local_outpu
Some PSA functions may not use these convenience functions as they may have local optimizations that reduce memory usage. For example, ciphers may be able to use a single intermediate buffer for both input and output.
In order to abstract the management of the copy state further, to make it simpler to add, we create the following 6 convenience macros:
For inputs:
* `LOCAL_INPUT_DECLARE(input, input_copy_name)`, which declares and initializes a `psa_crypto_local_input_t` and a pointer with the name `input_copy_name` in the current scope.
* `LOCAL_INPUT_ALLOC(input, input_size, input_copy)`, which tries to allocate an input using `psa_crypto_local_input_alloc()`. On failure, it sets an error code and jumps to an exit label. On success, it sets `input_copy` to point to the copy of the buffer.
* `LOCAL_INPUT_FREE(input, input_copy)`, which frees the input copy using `psa_crypto_local_input_free()` and sets `input_copy` to `NULL`.
For outputs:
* `LOCAL_OUTPUT_DECLARE(output, output_copy_name)`, analogous to `LOCAL_INPUT_DECLARE()` for `psa_crypto_local_output_t`.
* `LOCAL_OUTPUT_ALLOC(output, output_size, output_copy)`, analogous to `LOCAL_INPUT_ALLOC()` for outputs, calling `psa_crypto_local_output_alloc()`.
* `LOCAL_OUTPUT_FREE(output, output_copy)`, analogous to `LOCAL_INPUT_FREE()` for outputs. If the `psa_crypto_local_output_t` is in an invalid state (the copy pointer is valid, but the original pointer is `NULL`) this macro sets an error status.
These macros allow PSA functions to have copying added while keeping the code mostly unmodified. Consider a hypothetical PSA function:
```c
psa_status_t psa_foo(const uint8_t *input, size_t input_length,
uint8_t *output, size_t output_size, size_t *output_length)
{
/* Do some operation on input and output */
}
```
By changing the name of the input and output parameters, we can retain the original variable name as the name of the local copy while using a new name (e.g. with the suffix `_external`) for the original buffer. This allows copying to be added near-seamlessly as follows:
```c
psa_status_t psa_foo(const uint8_t *input_external, size_t input_length,
uint8_t *output_external, size_t output_size, size_t *output_length)
{
psa_status_t status;
LOCAL_INPUT_DECLARE(input_external, input);
LOCAL_OUTPUT_DECLARE(output_external, output);
LOCAL_INPUT_ALLOC(input_external, input);
LOCAL_OUTPUT_ALLOC(output_external, output);
/* Do some operation on input and output */
exit:
LOCAL_INPUT_FREE(input_external, input);
LOCAL_OUTPUT_FREE(output_external, output);
}
```
### Implementation of copying validation
As discussed in the [design exploration of copying validation](#validation-of-copying), the best strategy for validation of copies appears to be validation by memory poisoning, implemented using Valgrind and ASan.